Skip to Main Content
Cookie Jar Kitchen logo topCookie Jar Kitchen logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Custom Orders
  • About
  • Sugar Cookies

Our Menu

CookiesBaked GoodsCookie AssortmentsIce Cream

Drop Cookies

Chocolate Chip photo

Chocolate Chip

$2.25

Oatmeal Raisin

$2.25
Funfetti photo

Funfetti

$2.25
Buttery sugar cookie filled and rolled in rainbow sprinkles

Ginger Molasses

$2.50

Cookie Sandwiches

These two sandwiches are consistently in the shop because they are so popular!

Oatmeal Cremè Pie photo

Oatmeal Cremè Pie

$6.50
Just like the childhood classic! Vanilla buttercream sandwiched between two oatmeal cookies
Funfetti Cookie Sandwich photo

Funfetti Cookie Sandwich

$6.50
Vanilla buttercream sandwiched between two funfetti cookies

Our breakfast item flavors rotate daily!

Menu for May 24

Orange Cranberry Scone photo

Orange Cranberry Scone

$3.50

Coffee Cake Muffin

$3.25

Cinnamon Donut Bread

$3.25

Lemon Poppyseed Scone

$3.50

By the Half Dozen or Dozen

Drop Cookies

Chocolate Chip photo

Chocolate Chip

$12.00/Half Dozen
$25.00/Dozen
Funfetti photo

Funfetti

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Oatmeal Raisin

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Cinnamon Toast Crunch

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Banana Cream

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Banana Bread Chocolate Chip

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Ginger Molasses

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Peanut Butter

$12.00/Half Dozen
$25.00/Dozen

Fruity Pebbles

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Lemon Blueberry

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Lemon Sugar

$12.00/Half Dozen
$25.00/Dozen

M&M

$12.00/Half Dozen
$25.00/Dozen

Orange Cranberry

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Strawberries & Cream

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Strawberry Pop Tart

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

White Chocolate Cranberry

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

S'Mores

$13.00/Half Dozen
$28.00/Dozen

Snickerdoodle

$12.00/Half Dozen
$25.00/Dozen

Cookie Sandwiches

Oatmeal Creme Pie

$36.00/Half Dozen
$75.00/Dozen

Funfetti Cookie Sandwich

$36.00/Half Dozen
$75.00/Dozen

Red Velvet Cookie Sandwich

$36.00/Half Dozen
$75.00/Dozen

Carrot Cake Cookie Sandwich

$40.00/Half Dozen
$82.00/Dozen

Oreo Cookie Sandwich

$36.00/Half Dozen
$75.00/Dozen

We offer half pints of ice cream from Harbor Creamery in Newburyport, MA.

Half Pints

Chocolate Milk & Cookies

$5.25
Oreo cookie ice cream with Oreo chunks! Harbor Creamery's all-time best seller.

Minty Chip

$5.25
HC's version has Ande's mint candy pieces!

Vanilla

$5.25
Pure organic madagascan vanilla

Coffee Oreo

$5.25
Coffee ice cream with Oreo chunks

Caramel Crunch

$5.25
Caramel ice cream with Heath Bar

Ice Cream Sandwiches

Our cookies with Harbor Creamery's ice cream. The perfect match! Flavors will be rotating.

Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

$7.50

Mint Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

$7.50
  • Catering